Kazakhstan has warned Giancarlo Ruiu, managing director of the North Caspian Operating Company (NCOC), of administrative and criminal liability for failing to pay a nearly $5 billion environmental fine related to the 'Kashagan' project. The dispute centers on sulfur storage violations identified in 2022, which led to a penalty upheld by the Atyrau Regional Court in June 2025. NCOC refuses to pay, citing interim measures from a UNCITRAL tribunal, while Kazakhstan argues these measures do not override domestic law.
Origin of the Penalty
The conflict began in 2022 when the Atyrau Region Department of Ecology identified approximately ten alleged violations at the consortium's facilities. Inspectors found that more than 1.7 million metric tons of sulfur had accumulated at the 'Bolashak' complex by November 1, 2022, exceeding the permitted limit of 730,000 tons. In early 2023, the regional environmental department issued a penalty notification for ₸2.356 trillion, which was approximately $5.4 billion at the time.
Legal Proceedings and Enforcement
In August 2025, a court set aside the original penalty notification due to procedural deficiencies but did not dismiss the environmental allegations. Following further domestic proceedings, the Atyrau Regional Court upheld the penalty on June 19, allowing the ruling to enter into force. On July 14, Kazakhstan’s Ministry of Justice stated the ruling was in force and gave NCOC until July 20 to pay voluntarily. After NCOC failed to pay by the deadline, the Justice Ministry warned Ruiu of liability for non-compliance.
Arbitration and Government Stance
NCOC stated on July 16 that a UNCITRAL tribunal issued interim measures directing Kazakhstan to refrain from enforcing the penalty while the case was pending. Kazakhstan’s Ministry of Justice rejected this interpretation, arguing that commercial arbitration does not limit the state's sovereign powers. The ministry argued that foreign interim measures have no automatic legal effect in Kazakhstan and do not prevent enforcing the final domestic court judgment. The government rejects claims of resource nationalism, stating it is enforcing domestic law and that investment agreements do not exempt the consortium from compliance.
Project: Oil project in Kazakhstan · Kazakhstan · In operation · $50 bn
Key facts
- The fine amounts to approximately $5 billion.
- Giancarlo Ruiu is the managing director of North Caspian Operating Company (NCOC).
- KazMunayGas was prepared to pay its share of the penalty despite foreign members' objections.
- Foreign shareholders have challenged the fine via ICSID treaty arbitration.
- NCOC continues to deny wrongdoing and claims enforcement is prohibited during arbitration.
All sources (1)
- Kazakhstan’s $5 Billion Kashagan Fine Moves Into New Legal PhaseThe Times Of Central Asia · · EN